Atos 15:10-11

Horae Homileticae de Charles Simeon

DISCOURSE: 1783
THE QUESTION ABOUT THE OBLIGATION OF THE CEREMONIAL LAW DECIDED

Atos 15:10. Now therefore why tempt ye God, to put a yoke upon the neck of the disciples, which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear? But we believe that through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ we shall be saved, even as they.

IT is a favourite idea with many, that the Gospels contain all that is needful for us to know, and that it would have been better for the Church if they only had been transmitted to us. But this is indeed to make ourselves wiser than God: for if God had not judged that the other parts of the New Testament would be useful to his Church, he would not have inspired men to write them, nor would he have preserved them for us with such peculiar care. We acknowledge that in the Gospels there are intimations of every thing which we need to know: but will any one say, that in the other parts of the New Testament there are not clearer explanations of them, or that the Gospels are not rendered far more intelligible by the light reflected upon them in the Epistles? Will any one say, that the purposes of God towards his Church, in the call of the Gentiles, the rejection of the Jews, and the future union of both Jews and Gentiles under one Head, are not more fully understood, than they would have been if the Acts of the Apostles had not been recorded? or that the correspondence between the law and the Gospel would have been so manifest, if it had not been pointed out to us in the Epistle to the Hebrews? We have now the advantage of knowing what objections were urged against the Gospel, and how those objections were obviated. To go no further than the passage before us: There was a controversy which agitated the whole Christian Church, insomuch that not all the authority of Barnabas or Paul were able to settle it: and a reference was made to the whole college of Apostles at Jerusalem for their decision of the point. That we may have a just view of it, we shall consider,

I. The subject in dispute—

The question was, Whether the Jewish law was obligatory on the Gentiles?
[This I say, was the original question; but it involved much more, even the whole plan of the Gospel salvation.
Many insisted that circumcision [Note: ver. 1.], and the observance of the whole Mosaic law [Note: ver. 5.], were necessary to salvation. They contended that these were of Divine institution; that the observance of them constituted the grand line of distinction between the Lord’s people, and all the rest of mankind; and that the severest judgments were threatened for a wilful neglect of them: and consequently, that they must be obligatory on the Lord’s people to the end of time. (It must be remembered, that the advocates of these opinions were not Jews, but Jewish Christians.)

On the other hand, it was maintained, that these laws were never imposed with a view to men’s justification by them; (for that Abraham was justified before even circumcision itself was ordained [Note: Romanos 4:10.]:)—that to require the observance of them from the Gentiles was contrary to God’s avowed design; (since he had manifested his acceptance of them in their uncircumcised state, precisely in the same way as he had of the Jews who were circumcised [Note: Atos 11:15.]:)—that it was impossible for any man to be justified by the observance of them; (since one single deviation from them would utterly condemn him [Note: Tiago 2:10.]:)—and that to blend the observance of them with the merits of Christ as a joint ground of our hope, was to invalidate the whole Gospel, and to make Christ himself of no effect to us [Note: Romanos 9:30.]—]

A question precisely similar is agitated amongst us at this day—
[Circumcision and the Jewish law are indeed, by common consent, rejected by us. But many amongst us proceed on the very same principle as those Judaizing Christians did, and make works, either ceremonial or moral, the ground of their hope before God.

Some, and some of no mean name, have gone so far as to assert, that the very act of baptism saves us. Verily, if such sentiments were not expressed in terms which cannot be mistaken, we should think it a libel to impute them to any man who calls himself a Christian, and much more to any one who would make his sentiments in theology a standard for the Church of Christ. It seems incredible that such Jewish blindness should exist at this day in the Christian Church.
Others, even the great mass of nominal Christians, imagine that the attending of the house of God and the Lord’s supper, together with common honesty, is sufficient to procure us acceptance with God; or that, if a little more be wanting, the merits of Christ will turn the scale.
Others, who come nearer to the Judaizing Christians of old, maintain, that though our hope is certainly in the Lord Jesus Christ, yet some works of ours are necessary to make his merits effectual for our salvation. This is a principle so generally avowed, that to controvert it would be called by many an unchristian heresy.
But (not to notice the two former opinions, which need only to be stated, and they will carry their own condemnation along with them,) this more specious principle is in reality founded on an ignorance of both Law and Gospel. For,

1. The moral law was not, any more than the ceremonial, given with a view to justify men: it was given rather to condemn them, and, as a ministration of death, to shut them up that they might receive life by the Gospel [Note: 2 Coríntios 3:7; 2 Coríntios 3:9; Gálatas 3:21.].

2. It is impossible that any man can be saved by his obedience to the law, because the law requires perfect obedience; which never has been, nor ever can be, rendered to it by fallen man [Note: Gálatas 3:10.].

3. To blend our obedience to the law with the merits of Christ, is to establish a ground for boasting; which it is the main scope and tendency of the Gospel to destroy [Note: Romanos 3:27; Efésios 2:8.].

4. Such an union of our works with the faith of Christ is declared to be an utter “subversion of men’s souls [Note: ver 24.],” and a superseding of all that Christ has done or suffered for us [Note: Gálatas 5:2.].

Here then the question, whether as debated formerly, or as existing at this hour, is fairly stated.]
We now come to,

II.

The apostolic decision of it—

And here we will view,

1. The Apostle Peter’s judgment respecting it—

[After the point had been long debated, St. Peter rose to give his opinion. His argument was extremely plain and simple. He reminded the Church, that the Lord Jesus had given to him the keys of the Gospel kingdom, and had commissioned him to open that kingdom both to Jews and Gentiles. To the Jews he had opened it on the day of Pentecost; and to the Gentiles about six years afterwards, when he preached to Cornelius and his friends: and on both occasions God had given the same testimony of his acceptance to the people, pouring out upon the uncircumcised Gentiles, precisely as he had done on the circumcised Jews, his Holy Spirit, both in his miraculous and sanctifying operations [Note: Compare Atos 11:15. with ver. 7–9.]. From hence he inferred, that God had unequivocally declared his mind and will, and had shewn, beyond all controversy, that in his eyes “neither circumcision was any thing, nor uncircumcision was any thing; but faith, that worketh by love,” was all that he required. To require therefore from the Gentiles an observance of the Mosaic law was to “tempt God, and to put on their necks a yoke,” which God had never intended to impose.

Having stated thus the grounds of his judgment, he proceeded to give, what we may call, his confession of faith. He viewed salvation as a free gift of God to man, for the sake, and through the merits, of the Lord Jesus Christ. This salvation he regarded as wholly gratuitous in all its parts, and as equally so both to Jews and Gentiles: to the Jews it was not given because they were circumcised: nor should it be withheld from the Gentiles because they were uncircumcised: both to the one and the other it would be freely given, the very instant they believed in the Lord Jesus Christ [Note: Compare the text with Romanos 3:29.]. No good works were required to merit it; nor was any thing required to make the merits of Christ more effectual: it was given freely, without money and without price; and from first to last must be wholly of grace.]

2. The sentence of the whole College of Apostles at Jerusalem—

[After Peter’s sentiments were delivered, Paul and Barnabas confirmed his argument, by stating what God had done among the Gentiles by them; and, by thus uniting their testimony to his, they convinced at once the whole assembly. James, who appears to have presided in the council, drew up the sentence in which the whole Church concurred. He appealed to Simeon’s, that is, Simon Peter’s, testimony, as exactly according with the words of prophecy: and then declared that no such yoke was to be imposed on the converted Gentiles. There were indeed some things which, under existing circumstances, it would be necessary for the Gentiles to forbear. They in their unconverted state had not merely regarded fornication as lawful, but had actually practised it in their idolatrous worship: they must therefore be especially on their guard against this, not only because it was sinful in itself, and therefore to be shunned by all, but because any approaches towards it would appear like a return to their former idolatry. On the other hand, there were some things forbidden to the Jews, such as “eating of things offered to idols, or things strangled, or the blood” of any animal; and it was necessary that the Gentiles should abstain from these things, lest they should put a stumbling-block in the way of the Jews, or cause disunion in the Church. But, as to their submitting to any rites, or their performing of any works, in order to obtain justification by them, no such thing was required, nor ought any such thing to be required: for, in fact, the requiring of them would only “subvert their souls,” and ruin them for ever.
Now this decision goes to the whole question as it now exists: for, if the performing of any act in order to obtain salvation by it, either in whole or in part, was unlawful then, it is unlawful now; and if it would subvert their souls, it will equally subvert and destroy ours [Note: Romanos 11:6; Gálatas 2:16.]

We shall conclude with,
1.

Some cautions respecting yourselves—

[In maintaining this doctrine, there are two cautions especially to be attended to: the one is, that you do not abuse it; and the other, that you do not ever lose sight of it.

Do not abuse it. If, by an indiscreet statement of it, you give reason to think that you despise morality, you will do incalculable injury to the souls of men. On the one hand, we must never be afraid to assert the doctrine of salvation by faith alone: but, on the other hand, we must shew the necessity of good works as fruits and evidences of our faith, and must declare in the strongest terms, that an unproductive faith is no better than “the faith of devils [Note: Tiago 2:19.].” We have only to distinguish between the foundation and the superstructure of a building. Every one can see that they are both necessary, though not necessary for the same ends: so they may see that both faith and works are necessary, though for different ends: both are good in their proper place: but they are good only for the ends and purposes for which they are required [Note: 1 Coríntios 3:11.].

Again: Do not ever lose sight of it. We see how even Peter himself was, not long after this, turned from the principles he had so firmly maintained [Note: Gálatas 2:11.]. So there is in us a wonderful tendency to lean to legal views, and self-righteous principles. Remember how jealous St. Paul was on this subject [Note: Gálatas 1:8.]; and “stand fast in the liberty wherewith Christ has made you free [Note: Gálatas 5:1.].”]

2. Some directions respecting others—

[As the oppugners of our principles are apt to be intolerant towards us, so it sometimes is found that we speak too contemptuously of them. Now it is certain, that many who have an unfeigned zeal for God, have very imperfect views of this subject [Note: Romanos 10:2.]: and they ought to be regarded by us with love, and be treated by us with the greatest tenderness. See how the whole Church met together to deliberate on this point for the satisfaction of their weaker brethren: and should not we exercise forbearance towards them, and labour with patience to lead them to clearer views of the subject? If God has given you a more just conception of this great mystery, be thankful for it; but make use of your knowledge, not for the indulgence of vain conceit, but for the edification of men, and the glory of God.

And whilst you seek the benefit of your fellow-Christians, do not forget your elder brethren, the Jews. “They have been broken off from their own stock on account of their unbelief; and we have been graffed in upon it:” remember them with pity, and strive by all possible means to promote their welfare. You see that the blending of their law with the Gospel was destructive to those amongst them who embraced Christianity: What then must be the state of those who reject Christianity altogether, and have no hope but in their law, which yet it is impossible for them, under their present circumstances, to obey? It is a shame to the Christian world, that we take so little pains to enlighten their minds, and to bring them to the knowledge of the truth. Consider then with yourselves what can be done for them, and how you yourselves in your respective stations may contribute to their good. And pray to God, that he will bring them back to his fold, and unite them with us under one Head, that “through the whole world there may be but one Lord, and his name one [Note: Zacarias 14:9.].”]

Veja mais explicações de Atos 15:10-11

Destaque

Comentário Crítico e Explicativo de toda a Bíblia

Agora, pois, por que tentais a Deus, colocando sobre a cerviz dos discípulos um jugo que nem nossos pais nem nós pudemos suportar? AGORA, PORTANTO, POR QUE TENTAR (OU ' TENTAR ') YEGOD - atrapalhand...

Destaque

Comentário Bíblico de Matthew Henry

7-21 Vemos pelas palavras "purificando seus corações pela fé" e o endereço de São Pedro que justificação pela fé e santificação pelo Espírito Santo não podem ser separadas; e que ambos são um presente...

Destaque

Comentário Bíblico de Adam Clarke

Verso Atos 15:10. _ AGORA, PORTANTO, POR QUE TENTAR A DEUS _] Um Deus, dando o Espírito Santo aos gentios , evidentemente mostra que ele não os designou para serem circuncidados, a fim de se tornarem...

Através da Série C2000 da Bíblia por Chuck Smith

E alguns homens que desceram da Judéia [à igreja em Antioquia] ensinaram aos irmãos, dizendo: Se não vos circuncidardes à maneira de Moisés, não podeis ser salvos ( Atos 15:1 ). Infelizmente, sempre h...

Bíblia anotada por A.C. Gaebelein

CAPÍTULO 15 _1. Os falsos mestres da Judéia. Paulo e Barnabé enviados a Jerusalém ( Atos 15:1 )._ 2. O Conselho em Jerusalém ( Atos 15:6 ). 3. O resultado tornado conhecido ( Atos 15:22 ). 4. A con...

Bíblia de Cambridge para Escolas e Faculdades

_Agora, portanto,_ quando você tem essa evidência de como Deus já aceitou os gentios. _por que tentais a Deus_ Diz-se que os homens "tentam a Deus" quando desconfiam de sua orientação e, em conseqüênc...

Bíblia de Estudo Diário Barclay (NT)

Os apóstolos e presbíteros se reuniram para investigar esta questão. Depois de muita discussão, Pedro levantou-se e disse: “Irmãos, vocês sabem que Deus nos escolheu desde os primeiros dias, para que...

Bíblia de Estudo Diário Barclay (NT)

O PROBLEMA CRUCIAL ( Atos 15:1-5 ) O influxo de gentios na Igreja produziu um problema que precisava ser resolvido. A formação mental do judeu baseava-se no fato de pertencer ao povo escolhido. Com ef...

Comentário Bíblico Católico de George Haydock

_Por que tentá-lo a Deus, questionando o que ele suficientemente atestou e aprovou, e por ser incrédulo em suas promessas de dar salvação aos gentios e a todas as nações. (Witham)_...

Comentário Bíblico Combinado

Veja as notas no versículo 7...

Comentário Bíblico de Albert Barnes

POR QUE VOCÊ TENTA A DEUS? - Por que provocá-lo ao descontentamento? Por que, desde que ele demonstrou sua determinação em aceitá-los sem tais ritos, você o provoca ao tentar impor aos seus próprios...

Comentário Bíblico de João Calvino

- 10. _ Agora, portanto, por que você tenta? _ Esta é a outra parte do sermão em que Pedro mostra quão mortal é essa doutrina que os inimigos de Paulo procuravam trazer; isto é, que pode afogar almas...

Comentário Bíblico de John Gill

Agora, por que tentam que Deus, hesitando sobre este assunto, contestando-se sobre este ponto, e buscando mais prova e evidências da vontade de Deus neste caso; Quando é tão simples, que tem sido sua...

Comentário Bíblico do Estudo de Genebra

(5) Agora, pois, por que (f) tentai a Deus, para colocar um jugo sobre o pescoço dos discípulos, que nem nossos pais nem nós fomos capazes de suportar? (5) Pedro, passando das cerimônias para a própr...

Comentário Bíblico do Púlpito

EXPOSIÇÃO Atos 15:1 Desceu ... e ensinou para o que desceu ... ensinou, A.V .; dizendo e dizendo A.V .; personalizado ()θος), por exemplo, A.V. Exceto que sejais circuncidados etc. A questão levantad...

Comentário de Arthur Peake sobre a Bíblia

A DELIBERAÇÃO. A reunião é pública (ver Atos 15:12 e Atos 15:22 ). Em Gálatas 2, Paulo diz que expôs sua maneira de pregar antes dos de renome, em particular. Pedro se apresenta (diz D, no Espírito) n...

Comentário de Coke sobre a Bíblia Sagrada

COLOCAR UM JUGO SOBRE O PESCOÇO, ETC. - "Um fardo doloroso e pesado, que nem nossos pais nem nós fomos capazes _de suportar com_ alegria e regularidade _,_ sem sermos expostos a grandes inconveniência...

Comentário de Dummelow sobre a Bíblia

A QUESTÃO DA CIRCUNCISÃO 1-35. O Concílio de Jerusalém, 49 d.D. A visão usual é que Gálatas 2:1 descreve a visita de São Paulo a Jerusalém por ocasião deste Conselho. Adotando isso, o seguinte foi o c...

Comentário de Ellicott sobre toda a Bíblia

WHY TEMPT YE GOD. — To tempt God was to make the experiment whether His will, manifested in the acceptance of the Gentiles, or man’s will, resenting and resisting it, was the stronger of the two. Noth...

Comentário de Frederick Brotherton Meyer

UM CAMINHO DE SALVAÇÃO PARA TODOS Atos 15:1 Paulo e Barnabé estavam descansando silenciosamente em Antioquia depois de suas árduas labutas, quando essas pessoas de Jerusalém furtivamente começaram a...

Comentário de Joseph Benson sobre o Antigo e o Novo Testamento

_E os apóstolos, etc., reuniram-se para considerar este assunto_ Como os apóstolos habitualmente residiam em Jerusalém, a maior parte deles pode ter se reunido nesta ocasião; e os élderes da mesma for...

Comentário de Leslie M. Grant sobre a Bíblia

No entanto, aqui em Antioquia surgiu um assunto de significado profundamente sério, e foi claramente a sabedoria de Deus ter Paulo e Barnabé ali naquela época. Homens da Judéia, professando o conhecim...

Comentário de Peter Pett sobre a Bíblia

“Agora, pois, por que você prova a Deus, para que ponha no pescoço dos discípulos um jugo que nem nossos pais nem nós pudemos suportar?” Agora, se Deus tivesse feito isso gratuitamente por esses genti...

Comentário de Sutcliffe sobre o Antigo e o Novo Testamentos

Atos 15:1 . _Certos homens que vieram da Judéia. _Epifânio diz que Cerinto, o herege, foi um dos principais nessa dissensão. Mas eles eram, sem dúvida, o envio do diabo, para inquietar os irmãos e afl...

Comentário do NT de Manly Luscombe

AGORA, POIS, POR QUE PROVAIS A DEUS, PONDO SOBRE A CERVIZ DOS DISCÍPULOS UM JUGO QUE NEM NOSSOS PAIS NEM NÓS PUDEMOS SUPORTAR? 1. Pedro conclui que qualquer imposição é "colocar um jugo" no pescoço d...

Comentário do Testamento Grego de Cambridge para Escolas e Faculdades

ΝΥ͂Ν ΟΥ̓͂Ν , _agora, portanto_ , ie depois de ter tido tanta evidência da aceitação de Deus dos gentios, tanto nos primeiros dias quanto nas viagens de São Paulo e Barnabé. ΤΊ ΠΕΙΡΆΖΕΤΕ ΤῸΝ ΘΕΌΝ; _por...

Comentário do Testamento Grego de Cambridge para Escolas e Faculdades

O CONSELHO EM JERUSALÉM; O DEBATE E O DISCURSO DE PEDRO. NARRAÇÃO DA OBRA DE BARNABÉ E PAULO...

Comentário popular da Bíblia de Kretzmann

AGORA, PORTANTO, POR QUE TENTAIS A DEUS A COLOCAR UM JUGO SOBRE O PESCOÇO DOS DISCÍPULOS QUE NEM NOSSOS PAIS NEM NÓS FOMOS CAPAZES DE SUPORTAR?...

Comentário popular da Bíblia de Kretzmann

A demanda dos ex-fariseus e a resposta de Pedro:...

Comentários de Charles Box

_UM RELATO DA DISCUSSÃO ATOS 15:6-21 :_ A igreja, com os apóstolos e anciãos, reuniram-se para discutir este problema relativo aos gentios e à Lei. Pedro disse que "Deus escolheu entre nós, para que o...

Exposição de G. Campbell Morgan sobre a Bíblia inteira

Na obra entre os gentios, a questão da circuncisão surgiu muito naturalmente, e sua dificuldade é revelada na convocação de um conselho. Esse conselho parece ter começado com muita discussão desconexa...

Hawker's Poor man's comentário

E os apóstolos e os anciãos se reuniram para considerar este assunto. (7) E havendo muita discussão, Pedro levantou-se e disse-lhes: Irmãos, vós sabeis que há muito tempo Deus escolheu entre nós que o...

John Trapp Comentário Completo

Agora, pois, por que tentais a Deus, a colocar um jugo sobre o pescoço dos discípulos, que nem nossos pais nem nós fomos capazes de suportar? Ver. 10. _Agora, portanto, por que tentais a Deus_ ] Ou (c...

Notas Bíblicas Complementares de Bullinger

TENTAÇÃO . Grego. _peira,_ tenta, coloca à prova. Sempre traduza "tentar" até este versículo, exceto João 6:6 (provar). Compare Atos 5:9 . COLOCAR . colocar. JUGO . Não apenas circuncisão, mas obrig...

Notas da tradução de Darby (1890)

15:10 colocando (d-8) O infinitivo, equivalente a 'em colocar'. É explicativo do que precede....

Notas Explicativas de Wesley

Agora, portanto - vendo estas coisas são assim: por que tentais a Deus? - Por que o provocais à raiva, colocando um jugo tão pesado em seu pescoço?...

O Comentário Homilético Completo do Pregador

_ANÁLISE HOMILÉTICA._ - _Atos 15:6_ O Conselho em Jerusalém; ou, a controvérsia da circuncisão resolvida I. A COMPOSIÇÃO DO CONSELHO .- 1. Os _apóstolos_ . Os doze; Paulo ainda não incluído em seu n...

O Estudo Bíblico do Novo Testamento por Rhoderick D. Ice

DEPOIS DE UM LONGO DEBATE. Alguns judeus acreditavam que Deus era sua propriedade pessoal e que os gentios tinham que aceitar sua Lei e Tradição e chegar a Deus por meio deles. Paulo e outros sabiam q...

O ilustrador bíblico

_E quando houve muita disputa, Peter se levantou._ DISCURSO DE PETER Marca-- I. A hora em que Peter falou. “Quando havia muita disputa.” Esse foi o momento crítico. Os discursos adquirem força a par...

O ilustrador bíblico

_E certos homens que tinham descido da Judéia ensinaram aos irmãos, e disseram: A menos que sejais circuncidados ... não podeis ser salvos._ PERTURBADORES DA IGREJA I. Certos homens vieram da Judéia...

Referências de versículos do NT no Ante-Nicene Fathers

Tertuliano sobre a monogamia às vezes pegam nas partes da lei que escolhem; também nós afirmamos claramente que a lei morreu neste sentido, que seus encargos - de acordo com a sentença dos apóstolos...

Série de livros didáticos de estudo bíblico da College Press

OS ANCIÃOS E OS APÓSTOLOS REUNEM-SE PARA RESOLVER A DISPUTA. Atos 15:6-29 uma. discurso de Pedro. Atos 15:6-11 . Atos 15:6 E os apóstolos e os anciãos se reuniram para considerar este assunto....

Sinopses de John Darby

O capítulo 15 contém o relato disso. Certas pessoas vêm de Jerusalém, onde tudo ainda estava acontecendo em relação aos requisitos da lei; e eles procuram impor esses requisitos aos gentios neste novo...

Tesouro do Conhecimento das Escrituras

Êxodo 17:2; Gálatas 4:1; Gálatas 4:9; Gálatas 5:1; Hebreus 3:9;...